| Platinum | The United Kingdom Shoppe |
| Gold | The Little Sugar Shack Bakery |
| Silver | Buns & Sweets Bakery |
| Bronze | Dooher's Bakery |
| Bronze | Hard Winter Bakery |
| Top Pick | A1 Gluten Free Gals |
| Top Pick | Black Honey Cafe |
| Top Pick | Emily Mae's Cookies & Sweets |
| Top Pick | The Boardwalk Board Game Lounge |
| Top Pick | Turnbull Cafe |