| Platinum | Primal Cuts |
| Gold | King Street Market |
| Silver | Franzs Butchershop & Catering |
| Bronze | Smokey Joe's |
| Top Pick | Flannigan's Butcher Shop |
| Top Pick | Maggie's Meat Market |
| Top Pick | Morello's Your Independent Grocer |
| Top Pick | One Fine Food |
| Top Pick | Otonabee Meat Packers |
| Top Pick | Sweet Beast Butcher Shop |