| Platinum | Tragically Dipped Donut |
| Gold | Dooher's Bakery |
| Silver | La Mesita Mexican Restaurant |
| Bronze | Double Dz's |
| Top Pick | Charlotte Pantry |
| Top Pick | Copper Spoons |
| Top Pick | Country Style |
| Top Pick | Kawartha Buttertart Factory |
| Top Pick | Providence |
| Top Pick | Two Dishes Cookshop |