| Platinum | Kollect This Inc. |
| Gold | The United Kingdom Shoppe |
| Silver | Things From Mom's Basement |
| Bronze | The Boardwalk Board Game Lounge |
| Top Pick | Avant-Garden Shop |
| Top Pick | Iceman Video Games |
| Top Pick | K and C Costumes |
| Top Pick | Madd Tea Party Boutique |
| Top Pick | Mastermind Toys |
| Top Pick | Peterborough Hobby and Games |