| Platinum | One Fine Food |
| Gold | Jim's Pizza & Pasta |
| Gold | Taso's |
| Silver | Papas Pizza Land |
| Bronze | Bar Vita |
| Top Pick | Buon Appetito Peterborough |
| Top Pick | Capra Toro |
| Top Pick | Pizza Villa & Pasta House |
| Top Pick | The Original Spaghetti House Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | The Pasta Shop |